Retreat for Tata, Adani, Essar: Gujarat scraps are ordered to pay more for power


In a setback to Tata Energy Mundra, Adani Energy and Essar Energy, the Gujarat authorities has gone again on its earlier determination to revise energy buy agreements (PPA), totalling 7,180 megawatt (Mw).

Based on state authorities sources, the sooner decision permitting these builders to cost larger tariffs, “now stands cancelled”. It would now signal supplemental PPAs with these items on a “case-by-case foundation” over and above the present PPAs.

The sooner decision was issued in November 2018 after a high-powered committee (HPC) shaped by the state authorities advised new phrases of PPA with value escalation to be shared by shoppers, lenders, and the challenge developer.

State authorities sources mentioned with the scenario altering in standard energy when it comes to diminished coal costs and maintaining supplementary PPAs in thoughts, the elevated tariffs have been changing into unviable for the federal government.

The discover by the state mentioned it could signal a supplemental PPA with Essar Energy. The one with Tata Energy is awaiting nod from the state authorities. Within the case of Adani Energy, the matter of a supplemental PPA is pending with the Central Electrical energy Regulatory Fee (CERC).

The choice by the Gujarat authorities comes every week after the Maharashtra authorities agreed to permit revised tariffs for Coastal Gujarat Energy.

ALSO READ: Covid-19 weighs on TCS numbers in Q1; web revenue falls 13.8% to Rs 7,008 cr

The Maharashtra State Electrical energy Distribution Firm just lately obtained the go-ahead from the state authorities to revise tariffs for CGPL.

Tata Energy in its newest annual report had talked about that CGPL may signal a supplementary PPA over and above the present one, at a better tariff with states. CGPL is the extremely mega energy challenge of Tata Energy in Gujarat’s Mundra. The discover by the Gujarat authorities mentioned the tariff at which CGPL indicators the supplemental PPA could be decrease than what it indicators with different states.

The annual report mentioned, “Based on the authorized opinion obtained, even when Mundra provides energy as per the tariff found via the aggressive bidding course of to 5 states underneath a single PPA, to be able to implement the HPC suggestions, CGPL can enter into separate supplemental PPAs with every procurer.”

The report added CGPL is following up with Gujarat and Maharashtra to signal separate supplemental PPAs.

Adani Energy Maharashtra (1,980 Mw) was commissioned in 2008 at a tariff of Rs 2.35 per unit and CGPL in 2012 at a tariff of Rs 2.26 per unit. Whereas Adani had a PPA with Gujarat and Haryana, CGPL had signed a PPA with Gujarat, Rajasthan, Maharashtra, Punjab, and Haryana.


In 2010, following an order by the Indonesian authorities growing its coal benchmark worth, the touchdown value of coal in India elevated. Adani and Tata, which have been importing from Indonesia, requested the CERC to grant them “compensatory tariff” for elevated gasoline value. This could have been handed via on the ultimate energy charges. The 2 builders got reduction by the CERC in 2014, then denied by the Appellate Tribunal for Electrical energy (APTEL), and once more awarded by the identical in 2016. In 2017, after states contested APTEL’s determination, the Supreme Court docket quashed any compensation to those items. It additionally directed the CERC “to compute a reduction, in keeping with the respective PPA”.

In the meantime, the Gujarat authorities shaped the HPC to formulate a reduction plan for imported coal-based crops on its territory. The HPC advisable capability cost or the fastened value of the unit to be diminished by 20 paise per unit (kilowatt-hour), following the lender taking a minimize on some portion of the debt reimbursement. The vitality/variable cost could be revised month-to-month and was capped at $110 per tonne for six,322 kilocalorie/kilogram grade of coal.

Any worth escalation past it could be borne by the developer. Energy builders repay debt via capability cost, whereas variable cost is the return on funding for the developer. The supplemental PPA would observe an analogous components, besides the vitality cost has now been diminished to $90 per tonne, from $110 per tonne earlier.

It was, nonetheless, solely Adani which obtained reduction as Tata Energy was requested to get approval from its 4 procuring states.

With inputs from Amritha Pillay